I’ve got a problem with these new pullets.
The biggest one, a partridge leghorn called Ash, has developed into a large and beautiful bird with a powerful personality to match. She’s now laid every day for nearly three weeks. One of the others has been crouching for a similar time and all 3 have red combs but none of them have actually laid.
Willow, the little CLB hybrid, is the smallest one, and Ash is by now twice her size and weight. Ash persistently bullies Willow, will go over to her and peck her hard for no reason.
A few days ago, Willow went badly lame. I pretty sure this was as a result of Ash attacking her, and possibly pushing her off her perch at roosting time. They have the choice of roosting in the coop, or on a higher perch in a covered sheltered area, and they have always preferred this. Willow was always the first one to fly up to the perch and go to sleep. The other two would soon join her, but Ash would pace around for a long time, calling, until it got really dark and she also went up to join them. One night I was watching to see what went on, and I’m sure I saw Ash blundering around on the perch, climbing over the other pullets to get to Willow at the end, and knocking her off her perch. Being asleep, she didn’t have a chance to spread her wings and she fell heavily to the ground. Next morning she was lame, holding up her right leg and having much difficulty walking. I examined her but couldn’t find any evidence of a break or dislocation, so I hoped it was some kind of muscle strain and would gradually heal. I wondered about taking her to the vet, but I don’t think it’s the sort of thing that they could help with, since anaesthetics and X-rays on chickens are not really possible.
Since then, some days she has seemed to be making progress, is able to take some weight on it, but still spends much time sitting down, and only walking around when she has to. I’ve lowered the perch so she can just hop up on it at night, which she manages OK, but she can’t get up to the low perch overlooking the garden where the others sit, or she chooses not to, so she misses out on that social contact.
Because she is now so awkward and slow to move around, and can’t get out of the way when she sees trouble coming, Ash has stepped up her attacks and Willow just sits there and takes it, it’s heartbreaking to watch. Ash will chase her away from the communal food plate in the afternoon, which is why I’ve taken to giving Willow a separate portion in a sheltered area in her own and standing guard whilst she eats it. Willow is otherwise fine, eating and drinking, pooing OK, just not very mobile.
I know you have to leave chickens to sort out their own pecking order, but this has gone on for so long and is affecting Willow’s life so badly, that I would appreciate ideas about how to deal with it. I don’t think it’s going to settle down with time, as Ash is the undisputed boss, and the other two are happy to let her be the top hen, and Willow is certainly no challenge, just the reverse.
So, dear friends, I need advice. What would you recommend? This can’t go on for the next 3+ years!
Here are the options as I see it.
1) Take Willow to the vet. As I said, unlikely to be helpful as investigations difficult, and during any recovery time she would still be bullied by Ash. If she had to be isolated, eg if her leg was splinted, this would make her position within the flock even more difficult. Any treatment likely to be very expensive -I would manage this as she’s such a sweetie, but is a consideration.
2) Ask the breeder I got them from if she would take Ash back and swap her for a less dominant, smaller pullets, not yet in lay. In which case I would also buy another pullet to make introductions easier, although this shouldn’t be a big problem at this time of year with pullets not yet in lay. Then I would expect one of the other two original pullets to take on the top role, and both of them are quite friendly to Willow.
3) Cull Ash, to remove the problem, and get two more instead; very reluctant to consider this as she’s a beautiful, healthy young bird and a regular layer.
4) Cull Willow. Unthinkable.